How many taverns in America can claim ties to George Washington, Benedict Arnold, and a Revolutionary War spy? The Haunted Old ’76 House in Tappan, New York, does just that—combining centuries-old patriotism with ghost stories that still echo through its walls. This colonial-era tavern has welcomed rebels, prisoners, and perhaps lingering spirits, making it a must-visit for history lovers and paranormal seekers alike.
Ghost Stories of the Old ’76 House
The Haunted Old ’76 House has earned a reputation for ghostly encounters tied directly to its Revolutionary War history:
- Major John André’s Restless Spirit: In 1780, authorities confined British spy Major John André here while he awaited execution. Many visitors report hearing footsteps and feeling cold spots near the area believed to be his cell. Some even claim André watched the construction of his gallows through the tavern’s windows.
- The Inverted Portrait: Above the fireplace, a portrait of Benedict Arnold hangs upside down. According to legend, George Washington himself ordered the reversal as a mark of betrayal. Guests often describe feeling uneasy near the portrait, especially when they learn its history.
- Unseen Presences: Patrons and staff frequently hear unexplained voices and clinking glasses, especially after hours. A few have even sensed someone watching them in otherwise empty rooms.
- Colonial Apparitions: Several people have reported sightings of shadowy figures in colonial garb. These spirits often appear near the fireplace or at the edges of candlelit dining rooms.
The Old ’76 House has earned attention from paranormal enthusiasts and media outlets alike. In 2015, Eater named it one of America’s most haunted bars, spotlighting tales of Major John André’s ghost. The Daily Voice featured a deep dive into the tavern’s chilling past and ghostly reputation, supported by input from paranormal investigators. On TikTok, creator @jonatales1 shared a popular video recounting André’s imprisonment at the tavern and the eerie legends that persist. These appearances keep the legend of the Old ’76 House alive for a new generation of haunted history fans.
A Historic Legacy in Tappan
Established in 1668, the Haunted Old ’76 House became a key site during the American Revolution. Officials used it as a temporary prison for British spy Major John André, who conspired with Benedict Arnold to surrender West Point. General George Washington reportedly dined at the tavern while 14 generals gathered to decide André’s fate. As a result, the tavern became a symbol of both justice and betrayal. Today, the Old ’76 House welcomes guests for colonial-era meals, live music, and stories of its haunted legacy.
Visiting Tips for a Ghostly Adventure
Ready to explore the haunted Old ’76 House? Here’s how to plan your visit:
Plan Your Visit: The Old ’76 House operates year-round, serving lunch and dinner. Reservations are recommended, particularly on weekends. For current hours and event information, visit their official website at 76house.com or call (845) 359-5476.
Details about hours, access, and events are accurate at the time of writing. Please check the location’s official website for the most up-to-date information before planning your visit.
Spooky Spots to Discover:
- Major André’s Cell: Explore the area where André was confined, and perhaps sense the lingering presence of the ill-fated spy.
- The Inverted Portrait: Observe the upside-down image of Benedict Arnold above the fireplace and reflect on its historical significance.
- The Fireplace: Feel the ambiance near the hearth, where many have reported sudden temperature drops and an inexplicable sense of unease.
- Dining Areas: Be attentive to subtle sounds and movements, especially during quieter moments, as if the past is gently whispering its secrets.
Dare to Explore the Old ’76 House?
This isn’t just a charming colonial tavern—it’s a portal to America’s revolutionary past, where patriotism and betrayal meet ghosts and legend. Whether you’re interested in a hearty meal or hoping to glimpse a spirit in the flicker of candlelight, the Haunted Old ’76 House delivers a history-rich haunt worth visiting.
