How many stories could linger within walls that once served as a morgue, icehouse, and speakeasy? Captain Tony’s Saloon in Key West, FL, offers just that—a bar steeped in history, mystery, and ghostly whispers. Built in 1851, this bar has seen everything from hurricanes to hangings, earning its reputation as one of Florida’s oldest and most haunted taverns. Today, visitors come not only for the drinks but also to experience the legends that echo through its dimly lit rooms.
Ghost Stories of the Haunted Captain Tony’s Saloon
Captain Tony’s Saloon is home to chilling tales and eerie experiences that continue to intrigue patrons and paranormal enthusiasts:
- The Hanging Tree: A large tree growing through the bar once served as a gallows. Guests report cold spots, strange shadows, and feelings of unease when seated nearby.
- Ghostly Woman in Blue: Several visitors claim to have seen the apparition of a woman in a blue dress, believed to be the spirit of a woman who was executed at the site.
- Unseen Hands: Bartenders have reported feeling taps on their shoulders or hearing their names whispered when no one is around.
- Morgue Residue: The building’s past as a morgue has led to reports of cold drafts, unexplained noises, and shadowy figures near the back rooms.
Captain Tony’s haunted reputation has appeared across popular media. It was featured on a 2012 episode of the Travel Channel’s The Dead Files, where investigators explored reports of restless spirits. The saloon was also highlighted in an episode of Mysteries at the Museum, discussing its morbid history. Paranormal YouTube channel Grimm Life Collective filmed their visit, documenting strange activity and ghost stories. The site has also been discussed on the podcast Lore, delving into its eerie past.
A Historic Legacy in Key West
The history of Captain Tony’s Saloon dates back to 1851 when the building first opened as an icehouse and morgue. Over the decades, it transformed into various businesses, including a speakeasy during Prohibition. In 1968, it became Captain Tony’s Saloon, named after former owner and local legend Captain Tony Tarracino. The saloon has hosted famous patrons like Ernest Hemingway and Jimmy Buffett, but its darker history—marked by executions, hurricanes, and violence—continues to fuel its haunted reputation.
Visiting Tips for a Ghostly Adventure
Ready to visit Captain Tony’s Saloon? Here’s what you need to know:
Plan Your Visit: The bar is open daily from 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM. Located at 428 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040, it’s a must-visit for anyone touring Old Town. Visit capttonyssaloon.com for more information.
Details about hours, access, and events are accurate at the time of writing. Please check the location’s official website for the most up-to-date information before planning your visit.
Spooky Spots to Discover:
- The Hanging Tree: This old tree inside the bar is tied to several executions and is a hotspot for ghost sightings.
- Back Room Morgue: Cold drafts and unexplained noises have been reported in the room where bodies were once stored.
- Woman in Blue: Visitors frequently report seeing her near the bar area before she vanishes.
- Barstool Whispers: Patrons claim to feel unseen hands tapping them or hear faint voices late at night.
Dare to Explore Haunted Captain Tony’s Saloon?
At Captain Tony’s Saloon, the past lingers like a shadow over every corner, from the old gallows tree to the backroom morgue. Whether you’re drawn by its historical significance or chilling ghost stories, step inside—you might find more than just a drink waiting.
